one issue, sadly he is not here to defend himself anymore
the main problem for me is that markets have their peaks and troughs, understanding these and benefiting form them is the hard part.
he never STR'd as he had nothing to sell, he was stationed in the UK by his employer, also he miscalled the slump by many years, and started crowing about buying Hong Kong and German property last year (or before) which has been hit very very hard.
it is rather like me now crowing that there will be a property boom, get in and buy now..... sooner or later i will be right and if in 6 years we are in a property boom i will claim i was right all along.....would i be a genius? Or just dogmatic whichver way i would be wrong just keep banging on and eventually i will be right
well here goes, we are in for the biggest property boom ever! get in and buy now, as much as you can i am the guru, i am the expert. I will spend the next 5 byears slaggimng off all those who disagree, and in a few years when prices start heading North at a pace i will be vindicated,
he funadmentaly did not understand property, this is evident in his posts, in fact one showed a glaring lack of knowledge, which is fine as one cannot know all things about everything, therefore i falied to see why he bothered to post on the subject, what he totaly missed is that in his mythical STR to invest the cash, he could have kept the property which would be worth double (or more) what it was when the STR claim was made, and still had the cash to invest
one also would like to now if the mythical investments have bucked the trend (he works for a firm that creates trading software for institutions, this was all found out ages ago), and he has lied behind the safety of his keyboad, thus for me has no credibility at all,
yes, some of what he said has come to pass, however mostly on guesswork and the fact that we have cycles in markets.
he was totally and utterly wrong in the timing, which was the most important thing, the fact that a downturn would occur frankly is a given, but calling it just about as wrong as you can get does not make you a genius
Rik